Summary

This is an ordinary civil lawsuit filed by Inversiones Empresariales, S.A. against Lisa, S.A. The case concerned preliminary objections raised by Lisa, arguing that the claim was defective and that the dispute should not proceed in ordinary courts.

Decisions

Eleventh First Instance Civil Court
January 20th, 2020
Issues

Preliminary objections raised by Lisa, including lack of jurisdiction, defective claim, lack of legal standing, and failure to meet procedural conditions.

Ruling

The Court denied most of the objections but upheld the objection of defective claim. Consequently, it rejected the ordinary lawsuit filed by Inversiones Empresariales, S.A.

Effect

The ordinary lawsuit filed by Inversiones Empresariales was rejected.

Order|Eleventh Civil CourtJanuary 20th, 2020

Conclusion

Lisa, S.A. prevailed. The Civil Court upheld Lisa’s objection of defective claim and rejected the lawsuit filed by Inversiones Empresariales. The court determined that the ordinary process was not the correct route, and the claim lacked the necessary legal requirements.