Appeal Ruling

Defendant's Petition

Galindo, Arias y López, counsel for Juan Luis Bosch Gutierrez, grounded the petition in Article 999 of the Judicial Code, which permits a court to modify its cost determination within three days of notification. The petition argued that Lisa, S.A. lacked standing to sue (legitimación activa) and that Bosch was not the depositary of the shares or dividends claimed, negating his standing to be sued (legitimación pasiva). Counsel invoked Article 1071 of the Judicial Code, which mandates cost awards against the losing party as the default rule and enumerates circumstances under which good faith cannot be presumed, including when no evidence is offered to support the claims in the complaint.

Tribunal's Analysis

The tribunal acknowledged the procedural viability of the petition, confirming it was filed within the three-day window under Article 999 of the Judicial Code, but rejected its substantive arguments. The panel held that, although Lisa, S.A.'s arguments did not succeed, it cannot be said that Lisa acted recklessly, abusively, or in bad faith. The tribunal emphasized that Lisa attempted to assert its rights in a complex legal context with documentary evidence that, while insufficient, was not entirely without foundation.

"Esta colegiatura se mantiene en el criterio en que la parte actora sostuvo su pretensión y aunque su argumentación no próspero, no puede afirmarse que haya actuado de forma temeraria, abusiva o de mala fe en este proceso." (Page 4)

Ruling

• By ruling of August 21, 2025, the court maintained Judgment No. 71 of July 9, 2025, issued by the First Superior Tribunal within <law id="pty-83573-21" />, brought by Lisa, S.A. against Juan Luis Bosch Gutierrez
• The exoneration of Lisa, S.A. from costs established in the <doc id="pty-83573-21-2025-07-09-a" /> of July 9, 2025 remains in effect

Legal Basis

• Article 999 of the Judicial Code — establishes the principle of immutability of judicial decisions, with an exception permitting costs to be completed, modified, or clarified within three days of notification
• Article 1071 of the Judicial Code — governs cost awards and good-faith determinations; the tribunal applied it to conclude that Lisa, S.A.'s exoneration was warranted

Signatories

• Miguel A. Espino G., Magistrate
• Yira Bernal González, Magistrate
• Carlos I. Pizarro H., Magistrate